Project Canterbury
Lancelot Andrewes
and Prayer
by Dr Marianne Dorman
Michaelmas, 1998
There is never a time when we do not “stand in need of God’s particular assistance”, nor a place in which we cannot pray. For Andrewes prayer should be ceaseless; it was like the burning of incense ever arising to the court of heaven. “‘Let our prayer go up to Him that His grace may come down to us,’ so to lighten us in our ways and works that we may in the end come to dwell with Him, in the light ‘whereof there is no even-tide.’” And ‘prayer goeth up, pity cometh down.’[1]
These quotations also reveal another aspect of Andrewes’ teaching on prayer. It is the channel by which we experience the generosity of the blessed Trinity. By this Andrewes not only meant that it is through prayer that we come to know God better, but also that it is only by the Holy Spirit working within us that we can prayer at all. Prayer is thus a gift of grace. So if we find ourselves not being able to pray, we must humbly ask for grace to be able to pray. Without prayer we sin, and so one of this divine’s terse remarks was that ‘prayer is good as it keeps us from sin.’
For many, their introduction to Lancelot Andrewes has been through his Preces Privatæ. For those who are familiar with this collection will know that his prayers are like a piece of tapestry as he weaves strands from the Bible, especially the psalms, the Hours, the Prayer Book and quotations from the Fathers. However this weaving is not tight but loose enough to allow for spontaneous prayer arising from daily life. The structure of his prayers follow the ancient five-fold pattern: confession, praise, thanksgiving, intercession and petition.
Prayer for Andrewes is essentially ecclesial and sacramental, and thus the Preces cannot be separated from Andrewes’ theology. It reveals his consciousness of continuing in the line of the Fathers, or indeed further back to antiquity when man first set up his altar to God, and therefore there was always an awareness of praying as part of that whole Church of God, the saints and sinners; the living and the dead. This is evident by what can be termed an anamnesis approach to his praying where he constantly recalled the various gifts God has given through creation, redemption and sanctification. He also firmly believed that Christ and the Church's teaching spoke as "one person", and that outside of the Church no Christian could receive Christ's blessings and grace which in time will bring them to "the glory, the joys, [and] the crown of Heaven".[2]
His praying as a member of Christ’s universal church was manifested as he embraced the whole cosmos, ranging from nature with all its wondrous details to the needs of those around him. Everything must be offered to God either in praise and thanksgiving for the whole universe or a confession of penitence for soiling it. He prayed "for all commonwealths of the world" and for all peoples, whether they worked in mines or courts. More particularly his prayers included all those who had been associated with him in any way during his life. So he prayed for his old school and master, college, parishes and cathedrals. Furthermore his bidding prayers supported his ecclesial teaching. In the fragility of the "whole Militant Church, scattred farre and wide over the face of the whole earth", he prayed for the preserving in it "those trueths that it hath recovered from the sundrie grose and superstitious errors of the former age". He also prayed for its unity which it daily seems to lose "through the unchristian and unhappy contentions of these dayes of ours".[3] In praying for the whole church he never forgot that the Church militant was part of the wider Church with its saints, especially the Mother of God and all heavenly beings. Thus in a prayer for the whole Church which is collated from the liturgies of James and Chrysostom it concluded:
Neither are we unmindful to bless Thee, for the most holy, pure, highly blessed, the Mother of God, Mary the eternal Virgin, with all the Saints:
Recommending ourselves and our whole life to Thee,
O Lord, our Christ and God:
For to Thee belongeth glory, honour, and worship.[4]
Overall his prayers ranged from his own sense of utter unworthiness and frailty to the grandeur and wonder of God, and from the humble needs of the individual to the wide needs of the State. There seemed to be nothing which escaped his prayerfulness. In praying for the dead he especially prayed for those who had committed suicide.
However the Preces Privatæ is not the only extant work of Andrewes’ prayers and his teaching on prayer. Shortly after his death in 1630 his amanuensis and chaplain, Henry Isaacson, compiled from Andrewes’ papers a collection of prayers to cover every aspect of life. As well as morning and evening prayers, there are eucharistic prayers, prayers in sickness and approaching death. Titled Institutiones Piæ or Directions to Prayer it also included the seven penitential and thanksgiving psalms respectively, a summary of Andrewes' teaching on the Lord's Prayer, Ten Commandments, repentance and confession.
There is yet another important work on prayer by Andrewes. Scala Coeli, first published in 1611, is the collection of nineteen sermons that he gave on prayer and the Lord’s Prayer in the 1590’s and its title is not without significance. In the Mediæval Church "Scala Coeli" was intricately bound up with indulgences to lessen the time of purgatory through prayers, masses, penances and good works offered for the dead, and at the beginning of the Henrician Reformation it was one of the abuses clearly to be put away. It had also been one of the pilgrimage cults of Westminster Abbey when in 1500 "Henry VII secured the ‘cala Coeli’ indulgence for requiem Masses celebrated in his new chapel".[5] On the title page, the editor, Francis Burton, depicted the purpose of these sermons, "the first sixe guiding to the true Doore" and the rest "teaching how so to knock thereat that wee may enter."[6] Hence prayer must always be the way to heaven, but offered simply in gratitude for what God has given without the implication of any leniency on Judgment day.
As these sermons obviously contain Andrewes’ teaching on prayer I have summarised them for this talk. In the first of these sermons Andrewes emphasised the importance of preparation in order to be able to pray aright. The first step is to acknowledge our own lack of holiness, goodness and sufficiency without God. That acknowledgement leads to the door of prayer, and on opening it, we will be led to confess our unworthiness and need for spiritual enlightenment, strength and humility. Then only will God give His grace to meet our needs.[7] In his own prayer life, Andrewes had a prayer called Before Prayer.
The second sermon was directed particularly towards those who thought they could pray in their own strength. This error caused men to forget that “‘every good giving and every perfect gift cometh’” from God, including the gift (what "St. Paul calls grace") to be able to pray. From grace there is a "spiritual" enlightenment and gradual progression "from one degree of perfection to another" for the rest of our earthly life. Thus it is only by grace that we can perfect the imperfect. This is what Andrewes often called growing in holiness in other sermons.[8]
The emphasis in the third was on obedience in praying according to Christ's precepts, and therefore "we may not think any longer it is a matter indifferent." This meant praying publicly in a set form, the kind of prayer which has been offered since antiquity, and as such is like incense rising to the heavenly court.[9] Therefore praying is not something we choose to do but rather what we are bound to perform as being "required as part of God's service" and "worship". For Andrewes Public Prayer, partaking in the Divine Liturgy with the whole Church is the great act of praying; far more important than our own private prayers, yet he did not belittle private praying. [10] He had this advice.
When thou awakest in the morning, shut and close up the entrance to thy heart, from all unclean, profane, and evil thoughts, and let the consideration of God and goodness enter in.
When thou art arisen and art ready, return thyself to thy closet, or other private place, and offer to God, the first fruits of the day, and in praying to him and praising him, remember,
1. To give him thanks, for thy quiet rest received, for delivering thee from all dangers, ghostly and bodily, and for all other his benefits to thee
2. Offer unto him thyself, and all things that thou dost possess, and desire him to dispose of thee and them, according to his good pleasure.
3. Crave his grace to guide thee, and to strengthen thee from, and against all temptations, that so thou mayest do nothing the day following contrary to his will.
4. And lastly, beg of him, (according to how we should pray) all things needful for the soul and body.[11]
Praying alone for Andrewes also meant those “private meditations and conferences between God and our souls”, the contemplative approach. Often in his liturgical sermons too he advocated this contemplative approach. For instance in his extant sermons for Good Friday he begged his auditors to spend much time simply contemplating the cross. “Blessed are the hours that are so spent!” he told them.[12]
Private praying is also closely linked with Christ's command to “‘ask, seek, knock;’” By obeying this command it helps us firstly to "see our want and need", so that we shall ask for them; secondly, it enables us to acknowledge that "we have lost ourselves", and so we seek; and thirdly it enables us to learn that without God's grace we are shut out of His presence and kingdom until we knock. Again Andrewes stressed our asking for the "spirit of grace and of prayer and ... then shall we have ability and power not only to seek the door, but when we have found it to knock at it." Why does Andrewes put so much emphasis on the door? The reason is that Christians have to learn "that when we come to pray to God the whole person must be occupied,’ that is, "the lifting up of our eyes... hands... [and] heart." Only then will the door open through which we shall "enter into His kingdom".[13]
Employing the right kind of knocking led Andrewes to teach on the correct posture for prayer, by following the example Christ gave. That way was kneeling and not sitting, but always in a reverend manner. He argued we cannot ask for grace, if we ourselves are "wanting unto grace".[14]
Andrewes in his fourth sermon stressed his ecclesial teaching. When we pray we are part of that whole church which prays unceasingly all over the world; however dispersed, the faithful always pray as "members of one body". These prayers are joined with those of "God's saints that pray for us with all instancy". Hence the main emphasis in prayer is not praying privately for ourselves but corporately so that when our praying is "faint" we are comforted by knowing that we not only have the saints and other Christians praying with us, but "our Head, Christ ....[who] ceaseth not to make request to God still for us." Of course it is He who prays in us and enables us to overcome our faintness and infirmities so that our prayers will proceed from the "fervency and zeal" of the spirit". By acknowledging that it is "the Spirit of God [which] maketh intercession for us", we shall not err "in spiritual things" as He "will make that prayer for us which shall be both for our good and also according to God's will". Furthermore praying as a member of the Church also teaches us that all Christians, living and dead, are bound together through the Holy Spirit.[15]
In the fifth sermon Andrewes suggested that we approach prayer through the eyes of the disciples who had learnt about prayer from observing Christ. From Him they had learnt three uses of prayer. One is "of necessity; for God hath left prayer to be our city of refuge, to the end that when all means fail we should fly unto God by prayer." The second is "of duty, for prayer is an offering", and in the sense is likened to incense, while the third is "of dignity" when prayer becomes a matter of being completely absorbed in God Himself. Thus like the disciples we can also learn to approach our Lord to "teach us to pray", and His response will be the same, "The Lord's Prayer". This is the model for all our praying, in which "there is not one word wanting that should be put in, nor any word more than ought to be," Andrewes suggested.[16]
In the last of these prayer sermon Andrewes emphasised once again the ecclesial aspect of prayer in Christ's Church as well as reiterating those themes of the previous five. One of these was that prominent theme of Andrewes, "obedience" to God, that is, we pray according to His precepts, which in turn means that "service and duty which we owe to Him." Such precepts direct that we pray at "certain hours": for lay-people that means "three times a day" and for the clergy "seven times a day" as set down in the psalms (ps.55.17, and ps.119.164). The place where we are to pray is "in His dominion" and so the first requirement for prayer is public where priest and people gather to worship God in "the Liturgy and the public service of God". In public prayer he emphasised the importance of the office of the priest who is the mediator between God and his people, and as such intercedes on behalf of them.
The Lord's Prayer, ever said by the Church, must be the framework of Public Prayer. There are four parts which are summarised under the two headings "of confession and petition". Under confession there is both confessionem fraudis, ... that is, "confession of sins", and "confessio laudis, that is, thanksgiving to God for His goodness in pardoning our sins, and bestowing His benefits upon us". With petition there is both "comprecation and deprecation". The former is seeking for good things, while the latter is desiring "that evil be removed". Associated with petitionary prayer is the prayer "proceeding from charity" which leads the Church to pray for all sorts and conditions of men, from those in authority to those with special needs such as the sick and poor.[17]
At the end of his last preparatory prayer sermon, Andrewes commented that "we have need to be instructed in the sense of the Lord's Prayer", that prayer "penned by our Saviour Christ on behalf of His disciples and His Church unto the end of the world". In accordance with this, he gave thirteen sermons on each petition respectively. Of all the prayers offered to God each day he described the Pater Noster as the prayer of charity and fraternity because there is no ‘I’ nor ‘mine’, nor ‘my’, but rather ‘our’ and ‘us’. It is ‘our Father’, ‘our bread’, ‘our trespasses’, and deliver ‘us’ from evil’.
Our Father